Alex Barnett blog

Stuff

The Joker gets an ID Card

Ever since I heard of the UK government's plans for an ID card system, I've felt for a number of reasons that it wouldn't work and that there would be 'unintended consequences', including making it easier for cybercriminals to commit large-scale fraud.

My primary concern has been the ability for the government to execute on their plans - let's face it, the UK government's track record in large scale IT projects is comparable to Eddie the Eagle's efforts in the Olympics (a British ski jumper who managed 56th position out of 57 competitors. The 57th was disqualified).

Since the original proposals, it seems that the UK government itself is realising the scale of this project is too ambitious and likely to fail - hence the recent scoping down. This is one of a number of 'risk management' tactics we'll read about as reality hits <the> home <office>. By the time they do eventually roll it out, it will look nothing like the original plan, will cost a load more than 'guessed' and will arrive years later than expected. And then they'll scrap it. And then they'll re-try it. Of course, I won't say I told you so.

One line of argument made by the pro-ID cards faction (er, the UK government) is to point out how well the ID programs are working overseas and how they are reducing benefit fraud increasing the security for all. Hmmm...I wonder what they might make of this Dutch joker:

"A man from Hellevoetsluis has managed to get an official ID card with a photo of himself made up to look like the Joker, from the Batman films. The man managed to get round strict new rules governing photos for ID cards and passports by saying the make-up and hat were part of his religious beliefs. The council gave the go ahead."

Posted: Jan 25 2007, 07:05 PM by alexbarnett | with 2 comment(s)
Filed under: ,

Comments

Sam Sethi said:

If someone wears a Muslim veil because of religious reasons can they hide their face?

I am also confused as to why I need a ID  when I have a passport that has my picture, birthday and my nationality (which would determine my right to work).

Why can't I just show that IF I have to carry any ID.    

# January 26, 2007 4:02 AM

TrackBack said:

# January 26, 2007 8:41 AM